Nick's Handmade Boots - Reviews and experiences

these boots are basically bombproof, so I bought another pair. I’m saying that after wearing my Builder Pros since December — they feel like tanks, but in a good way. The Nicks 1964 leather pulls up and ages into a great patina, and honestly the scuffs look nicer than the pristine version ever did. I ordered my usual boot size (I’m UK10/US11) and the 11 fits like a glove. Had better and worse luck with other brands, but these genuinely surprised me.

bring patience and a clear timeline.

Not for me — they run so narrow and the sizing is just off. I ordered my usual size 12 C and ended up with what felt like an 11.5 E, and no, that didn't help. If you have pin‑point narrow feet these could be fine, but for normal feet they're brutal even after breaking in. Kinda glad I tried them so I didn't hang on to them. Also, told rebuild was $300 but charged $350 — ugh.

confirm the size on the box and get refund details in writing. Disappointed — practical product ruined by sloppy service.

I had heard some good things about this boot maker, and I have to say, they really delivered. The leather they use in their boots is top-notch, way better than other brands you find in stores. You can tell they put a lot of care into making sure there are no mistakes in their work, it's all so well-crafted. Plus, the folks working there were super helpful in helping me find the right size for my feet. All in all, shopping there was a great experience and I couldn't be happier with the awesome boots I got.

I bought a pair of Builder Pro boots from this store not too long ago, and let me tell you, they are tough as nails! The leather they use is super durable but also looks really nice with a great pull-up. The quality is top-notch, so I know these boots are gonna last me a long time. I was so impressed that I ended up getting another pair, the Renegade, just 7 months later. I usually wear a UK size 10 or US size 11 in boots, so I went with an 11 and it fits like a glove.